I beg your pardon for the title, before you carry your salu-bata and slap this weblog into oblivion.
The talk is about Madonna, mind you, she’s not the only celebrity that is investing in Africa in terms of international child adoption. This is soon to become a formalized business, and in the next couple of years, our exported kids might become rappers, singers and international celebrities in their own rights, all with a very damaged view of Africa. See, even if you don’t know where Malawi is on the world map, by the time you search for the word ‘Madonna’ on Google, Malawi will pop up somewhere, and you’ll make the connection in no time.
I honestly wonder what Madonna wants to achieve by adopting Malawian kids. I asked a colleague of mine and he joked: ‘maybe Madonna was originally from Malawi…..home is where the heart is’. I thought for a minute if she could be black under her white skin.
Are there no poor, hungry, naked and disadvantaged American / European kids that Madonna can adopt – even if the kids belong to a newly arrived illegal immigrant? Is every American child in school already? are there no beggars there? does every child have a home, good parents, toy cars and dolls, more than enough food to eat? doesn’t any child need help in America? are there no sick children that need free medicare? Why does Madonna have to cross the whole world to find a little black boy that needs help, and in Malawi for that matter? While she points at others, are her other fingers not pointing back at her?
If I was an American kid that needed a good home, won’t I accuse her of neglecting me and going to Africa to help someone else? first, to add insult to the injury? where is the American Nationalistic Pride and love for man and country? even if she cannot help black American kids, how about the whites?
p.s: I’m not hating, I’m just trying to put myself into someone else’s shoes. And just like a lot of others have been / are still saying:
- why arent celebrities adopting US kids?
- Madonna to adopt 3-year old girl, Mercy
- whats wrong with adopting American kids?
- Madonna lashes adoption critics
- Its not just about Adoption
- Madonna to adopt Indian girl
I understand that fingers are not equal, but by the time you compare David’s pic(left: David with Madonna’s husband) to the one on this post (a naked child sucking his mothers breasts), we might as well give Madonna a thumbs up for her act, and even a PhD degree to boot.
I understand there are poor people everywhere, but does one good deed deserve another?
Now, let me get to my main talk for this post: what is the difference between Madonna and the typical Nigerian woman?
I asked a friend if it was possible for a Nigerian married Yoruba woman to go and adopt a total-stranger-child who is of, for example, Ibo origin. he said “No, such ‘would first’ try to adopt a Yoruba originated child, especially if such is a near/distant relative”. I asked ‘why’, and then he began talking in the tribalistic ‘help your own people first’ line. My friend (CK) is of Ibo origin. He also informed me that an Ibo couple/woman would prefer to adopt an Ibo-origin child first, rather than a total stranger yoruba/hausa/another tribe child etc. Can we take such an attitude to be generalized in every hook and corner of Nigeria? maybe Yes.
I had to ask CK who he thinks the average Nigerian considers ‘his people’: is it anyone called a Nigerian or someone specific from the same tribe? The latter(same tribe) was the unfortunate answer.
Then I asked if it was possible for this Nigerian woman to go to other African countries and adopt children. He again started in the ‘what would people say’ line etc. Ok, what would the people say? ‘They might think you are using the children to make money’ – now thats a problem, isn’t it.
Can we say that Madonna (one among other celebrities in the International Child adoption virtual ring) is doing what the typical Nigerian couple / woman(in this example) cannot do by default? This is harsh, but isn’t it the truth: that this typical Nigerian woman (wife, mother, etc)?,….pls note ‘typical’….. perhaps as a result of cultural, family, societal and religious upbringing and influence, etc, has no time to make primary provision for children that do not come out of her own body? She would strive tooth and nail, endure the hardships of an uncaring husband(if need be), just so that she can have a child of her own – for which she can boast a 9-months-carrying-in-the-womb. And once she has it, once she gives birth to her own child, she feels an all encompassing sense of fulfillment, achievement, and final arrival. She doesn’t care how many children other people have, at least she has one of her own. Mommy would love and care for her own child and could go any length to ensure the welfare of ‘that child’ that came out of her womb.
And should mommy have a house help (boy or girl who could be a relative or total stranger), won’t it be very easy to identify who the house-boy or house-girl is? The physical appearance of the house-help spells the first difference. While junior is served a bowl of rice and meat, the house-help receives half a plate of rice with no meat. The struggle continues, until Junior begins to feel he is a human being and the house-help an unfortunate soul.
Madonna must surely feel a passion to help someone who cannot repay her, for her to step outside American shores to adopt Africans. It must be a sense of fulfillment that drives her to do what people might generally consider odd in her adoption endeavors? Or perhaps she has a vision for Malawi that others don’t have, including Malawi itself.
And what of the Nigerian woman, wife and mother. Can she choose to help someone who cannot say thank you? someone with no means to do her a re-favor? can she be so into something that goes against what people would say? will the definition of ‘my son’ or ‘my daughter’ change from the 9-months in my womb status quo?
There are so many lessons to learn in life and are there not so many differences between Madonna and the Nigerian woman?
have your say!




osunyemi
April 13, 2009
Many changes are manifesting due to the 21st century modern, american world focus on africa. those changes affect us and africa. as an african american, i have looked to nigeria as the place of my ancestors, my ancestral religion, my family genetic and otherwise. but i am an american, i can have a romantic ideal of africa but i can not practice the indigenous religion as a native. but i think this is good. what i see as some practices that are wonderfully traditional but also amazingly feudal as social modalities. i must make this culture nourish me but i can not mindlessly follow instructions that no longer work just because they are rooted in a past. wow the whole patriarchy thing, i must support and i must embody a rebellion against it also, as an american 21st C, gone through the civil rights movement, gone through feminism, gone through therapy, gone through meditation… being free is most important. I am an experiment, i have nigerian friends, i will soon have two young nigerians come to live with my husband and i for two years. so lets see how we change each other!
2009cupofcoffeechallenge
April 13, 2009
Maybe we need to look less at who births the mother and more at who is willing to mother the child.
While I have only 1 child myself, I am of the belief that we parent all the children of the earth merely by living at this time – and as such we do what we are capable of in whatever way we can.
For me this means making a difference day by day through the 2009 Cup of Coffee Challenge.
If I were Madonna (and other celebrities) I would use my position to highlight the imbalances and injustices that are perpetrated on children. And I think I would make this as personal a mission as I could, maybe this is what Madonna is doing?
Every child needs love and care, but we as individuals are just that, an individual – and there is only so much we can do – I’m glad that celebrity mothers are bringing this out for us to have a look at.
May the conversation and then action change our world for the better.
Melody
rainerdoost
April 14, 2009
yes this seems to be a very African concept of each one being the mother to each child.
rainerdoost
April 14, 2009
Osunyemi. my wife just responded using my name. It’s ok, I just wanted to clarify! Hey I got her hooked on you!
Now turning to your blog, thank you for raising so may important questions for our post modern world.
I have been married to Osunyemi, a “black” woman for nearly 16 years. I love her skin and her lovely 60 year old body but most especially her different (from mine) mind. Is there a problem with being enthralled with what is different?
What is the problem with Madonna or any one else being attracted to beautiful brown children. Will she love and nurture the chosen one to flower into it’s unique being, that is the only meaningful question. Concerns about skin color and ethnicity are a sad commentary on those who raise them.
poeticmocha
April 14, 2009
I think liking what is different-there is no problem with that. I think every individual likes what they like because everybody is made differently and thinks differently as well. I think liking what is different is fine and it can be a good thing as well because if everyone liked things that are ordinary-what would happen to the things that are different? People cannot like the same things. Therefore, what a person likes needs to be respected and understood. As long as someone doesn’t like something that is TOO different-for example-something that is illegal or not allowed-than that is a problem but that is another topic.